2018 Annual Meeting
In This Section
Luncheon speaker Judge Kara Stoll of the Federal Circuit provided interesting insight into the Court’s views on Friday, October 26, 2018. The former Finnegan partner, who joined the Federal Circuit in 2015, spoke about her passage into public service. “In some ways it was an easy transition,” she told Lisa Jorgenson in an interview during the luncheon. “I didn’t have to worry about losing any cases and my clients always pay.”
But she says the sheer number of cases has been challenging. On the subject of rehearing petitions, Stoll raised a gripe. “For what it’s worth, I really think the court and the bar would be well served if there were more selective use of petitions for rehearing. Then the ones that are really deserving, exceptional issues of importance, would stand out a little more.”
Stoll observed that “occasionally, and maybe even often”, cases have a large time gap between when an appeal is filed and when oral argument is scheduled. “One thing I noticed was the delay wasn’t necessarily due to the court’s action,” she said. “We seemed to be keeping up, but in some cases counsel for both sides or just one side would identify months on end when they are not available for oral argument, and not necessarily explain why or give good cause.” She added: “It is something we are going to look into and something that is important to us because we want to keep up with our docket.”
Stoll discussed the number of issues that should be raised on appeal. The Federal Circuit has counseled for years that raising more than three issues can be difficult because of the limited amount of space in a brief and because weaker arguments can make stronger arguments appear weak. “We receive a number of appeals still where there are five or six issues raised, or the issues raised are questions of fact,” said Stoll. “For our review of PTAB appeals, the standard of review is substantial evidence. We see a lot of appeals where somebody is arguing that there isn’t substantial evidence to support a fact finding by the PTAB when in fact there is. So one thing that would behoove the bar would be to think about that substantial evidence standard and also think about legal issues.”
AIPLA Executive Director Jorgenson asked Stoll what distinguishes a good appellate lawyer from a great appellate lawyer. “It is really knowing the record well so that during oral argument you are faster with the record and the facts,” explained Stoll. At oral argument, the judges have already read the briefs and studied the relevant issues. They have to vote immediately after oral argument on the outcome of the case. “So a great attorney at oral argument really hears the question and answers with a yes or no and an explanation if necessary,” Stoll said. “They really know the record and the case law and are willing to make concessions, both in terms of what the facts are. But also if the attorney isn’t familiar with the particular case that you are asking about, it is better to admit you don’t know than to pretend you do.”
Stoll also gave some advice about writing briefs. She said that many briefs do not dig into the facts as much as necessary. One example of an error is saying a client should win because of a certain case and then just citing that case. A great brief would give the facts of the cited case and explain why the current case is just like it and why the court should rule the same way. “I am really surprised by the number of briefs that tackle the issues not at a level of depth that I need in order to be able to resolve the case,” said Stoll. “So I think that’s one thing that distinguishes a great brief from a good brief.”
The AIPLA Annual Meeting began in earnest on Thursday, October 25, 2018, with a very timely presentation during the Opening Plenary Session. Daniel Lee, Assistant US Trade Representative (Acting) for Innovation and Intellectual Property Office of the US Trade Representative (USTR), provided an overview of the United States-Mexico- Canada Agreement (USMCA), which was agreed in the very last few hours of September.
“I am happy to say that the IP chapter of the USMCA is the most robust IP chapter that USTR has ever negotiated,” said Lee. “It covers protection and enforcement across the IP spectrum, including trademarks, patents, trade secrets and copyright. The USMCA will raise the standard of IP protection and enforcement in Canada and Mexico. It also serves as a loud and clear signal to other countries as to what the United States expects for IP protection and enforcement.”
The USMCA includes many IP changes. “The real winners are US innovators and creators,” said Lee. The IP chapter includes provisions on biologics, trademarks, geographical indications, pharmaceutical patents, copyright and trade secrets.
AIPLA CLE Webinar: Shining a Light on Litigation Funding
December 13, 2023 12:30 PM to 2:00 PM | Up to 90 Mins Ethics CLE PendingJoin Emil J. Ali and Julia Haines as they shine a light on litigation funding and discuss the special implications on patent litigation. This ethics CLE will focus on the pros and cons of litigation funding, the ethics rules implicated with such relationships, as well as the recent interest and disclosure obligations in certain jurisdictions.
2024 AIPLA Virtual Corporate Practice Institute
January 9 to 16, 2024 | Up to 360 Minutes of CLETuesday, January 9, 12:00 Noon - 5:00 PM - and Tuesday, January 16, 12:00 Noon - 5:00 PM -- The Corporate Practice Institute is a virtual event will take place on the 2nd and 3rd Tuesday of January, and will consist of 60 minute Sessions with 30 minute breaks in between. Each evening will end with an online networking event. Program Coming soon! Special registration rates for in-house corporate practitioners.
2024 DEIA Colloquium
January 30 to February 1, 2024On January 30-February 1, 2024, AIPLA will be leading a Colloquium focused on “Incentivizing Innovation, Entrepreneurship and Creativity Through Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Accessibility.” We hope you can join in that dialog, which will include presentations by IP offices, IP associations, law firms, corporations and universities. They will share their insights on the issues facing their organizations and the unique approaches they employ to maximize inclusion in the innovation ecosphere. As a result of our discussions, the Colloquium will develop a Statement of Principles as a culmination of the panel sessions and workshops. Look for more information and Registration materials soon, so you can join in the stimulating program, and social events at a beautiful mid-winter venue. Attendance is by invitation.
2024 Patent Prosecution Boot Camp - San Jose, CA
February 7 to 9, 2024Register today and don't miss out! The Patent Prosecution Boot Camp is a comprehensive, CLE-accredited seminar that includes instructional lecture-style sessions with practical tips on U.S. and international patent preparation and prosecution, as well as hands-on interactive workshops that will walk you through drafting claims and responding to office actions.
2024 Trade Secret Summit
March 14 to 15, 2024Save the Date! Please join the AIPLA Trade Secret Committee for the 2024 Trade Secret Summit, which is being held March 14-15, 2024 in Santa Clara, California. The AIPLA Trade Secret Summit is the leading trade secret conference in the nation, with speakers from across the spectrum of private practitioners, in-house counsel, government, and academia, as well as fantastic networking opportunities. Registration and Venue Information Coming Soon!