EZAKI GLICO CO. v. LOTTE INTERNATIONAL AMERICA CORP., Docket No. 20-1817, amicus brief filed 7/29/2021
All documents are in PDF format.
On July 29, 2021, AIPLA filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court case, Ezaki Glico Co. v. Lotte International America Corp. (Case No. 20-1817). The issues presented were (1) whether trade dress is “functional” if it is “essential to the use or purpose of the article” or “affects the cost or quality of the article,” as the Supreme Court and nine circuit courts have held, or if it is merely “useful” and “nothing more,” as the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit held below; and (2) whether the presence of alternative designs serving the same use or purpose creates a question of fact with respect to functionality, where the product’s design does not affect cost or quality and is not claimed in a utility patent.
The brief addresses the Third Circuit’s conclusion that product design trade dress is functional, and therefore not protectable, if it is “useful.” This sweeping conclusion sidesteps the “traditional rule” applied in the Supreme Court cases of Inwood Laboratories, Qualitex and TrafFix that product design trade dress is functional “if it is essential to the use or purpose of the article or if it affects the cost or quality of the article.” The decision paints with too broad a brush. It makes all product design trade dress more vulnerable to invalidation because all product design trade dress is “useful” in some way or form.
The brief also questions the Third Circuit’s displacement of what remained of the traditional rule with principles of the separate doctrine of aesthetic functionality. Moreover, because trade dress is typically associated with ubiquitous products (especially the trade dress that is copied), it is likely that a trade dress owner would be forced to defend its trade dress in the Third Circuit under the new rule.
To read the full brief, please download the file.
AIPLA 2021 Annual Meeting On-Demand!
May 28 to August 1, 2022 | Virtual Attendees can receive 1,140 CLE minutes, including 90 minutes of Ethics for the on-demand sessions.AIPLA's 2021 Annual Meeting is now available on-demand. View all the sessions presented by some of the best IP professionals in the industry.
2022 Mid-Winter Institute On-Demand
May 28 to July 31, 2022 | 915 on-demand CLE minutes, including 60 minutes of EthicsAIPLA's 2022 Mid-Winter Institute is now available on-demand. In a fast changing world where technologies have followed suit, IP professionals around the world face the challenge of acquiring the right tools to fully protect cutting edge innovations.
2022 Electronic and Computer Patent Law Virtual Summit
June 15 to 16, 2022 | TBDThe Electronic and Computer Law Committee’s June Roadshow has gone virtual! Join us June 15 & 16 as we explore topics relevant to electronic and computer patent law, and earn plenty of CLE credit along the way.
2022 Design Rights Boot Camp - Arlington, VA
June 23 to 24, 2022 | 710 Minutes of CLEThe Design Rights Boot Camp is a first of its kind two-day comprehensive CLE program designed for both new and experienced IP practitioners who wish to learn about protecting and enforcing designs in all areas of IP, including design patents, copyright and trademark dress. Join us for this in-person event!
AIPLA 2022 Annual Meeting
October 27 to 29, 2022To be held at the Gaylord National Resort and Convention Center in National Harbor, MD.