News & Publications
Find our latest news and analysis here. From the daily Newsstand to the Quarterly Journal, we cover the full breadth of intellectual property law.
Written September 5, 2019
The US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on August 27, 2019, reversed a grant of summary judgment in favor of a Utah vape shop in a trademark infringement suit. Affliction Holdings LLC v. Utah Vap or Smoke LLC, 10th Cir., No. 18-4146, 8/27/19.
Affliction is a California clothing company known largely in connection with mixed martial arts. It sued Utah Vap or Smoke LLC for infringing a trademark made of an upside-down fleur-de-lis inside a circle with the words “Affliction Live Fast” in Gothic lettering. Utah Vap’s marks have a right-side-up fleur-de-lis inside a circle with the words “Vape Affliction” in a different font. The district court granted Utah Vap summary judgment, ruling that no reasonable juror could find a likelihood of confusion between the marks.
The Tenth Circuit reversed because marks are highly similar and Affliction’s mark is “both conceptually and commercially strong,” which created a genuine fact issue as to whether confusion was likely.
Affliction is a California clothing company known largely in connection with mixed martial arts. It sued Utah Vap or Smoke LLC for infringing a trademark made of an upside-down fleur-de-lis inside a circle with the words “Affliction Live Fast” in Gothic lettering. Utah Vap’s marks have a right-side-up fleur-de-lis inside a circle with the words “Vape Affliction” in a different font. The district court granted Utah Vap summary judgment, ruling that no reasonable juror could find a likelihood of confusion between the marks.
The Tenth Circuit reversed because marks are highly similar and Affliction’s mark is “both conceptually and commercially strong,” which created a genuine fact issue as to whether confusion was likely.
Broadcast Opportunities
Looking for opportunities to get published? Submit your work to the AIPLA Quarterly Journal or AIPLA Innovate Magazine.
Exhibitor and Sponsorship Opportunities
Highlight your brand at a premier intellectual property law event, webinar, podcast, or in one of our publications.
For rates, availability, or additional details, click here or contact:
Meghan Donohoe
COO
American Intellectual Property Law Association (AIPLA)
T| +1.703.415.1343
E| mdonohoe@aipla.org