Navigate Up
Sign In

Wednesday, December 6, 2017 Webinar

12:30 - 2:00 pm Eastern


Proper Combination of References for Obviousness (KSR v. Teleflex Progeny)​

 Course Description:


Think you know when it's proper to combine references when presenting an obviousness argument? Think again!  This presentation clarifies the overgeneralization that the 2007 Supreme Court decision in KSR v. Teleflex has suffered, almost from its first publication.  The KSR case stands for much more than most casual observers understand, and this presentation highlights key language within KSR that demonstrates when two references can be properly combined, and when they cannot.  Various technologies are also touched upon in the Federal Circuit cases that interpret KSR, and this presentation explores such caselaw to help understand how to properly combine references, and how to explain when such combinations are improper.

Presented by:  Frederick Gibb of Gibb & Riley, LLC; Gregory Stone of Whiteford, Taylor & Preston L.L.P.




Registration Fees Per Site:    
AIPLA Member 
General/Non-Member Rate
Single Site (1) $95 $195
2-10 Attendees per Site
All attendees must participate at the same location.
$295 $350
11-20 Attendees per Site
All attendees must participate at the same location.
$445 $495
21+ Attendees per Site
All attendees must participate at the same location.
$595 $650
Registration includes:
  • For multiple-attendee sites, all participants must attend at the same location.
  • CLE certification/processing for applicable states.  Reference CLE Information below for complete details.  
  • Webinar materials, including complete CLE processing information, accessible 24-48 hours before webinar date.

Cancellation Policy: 
To get full refund, registrant must request refund 
five (5) days prior to live event. If less than five (5) days, registrant is transferred to product.
AIPLA MEMBERS: Did you know AIPLA offers our Solo-Practitioner members a special registration rate of $65 for all CLE webinars?  Please contact AIPLA directly at to complete your registration or access the registration form here. 

System requirements: 
Webinar access is compatible with any Windows 7 or later computer, Android OS devices, or Apple/iOS devices.  Check system compatibility here.
Accessibility for hearing impaired:
AIPLA’s webinars are available and accessible to individuals who are hearing impaired. If anyone at your location would like to know more about accommodations, please contact We ask that you let us know at least 7 business days out from the webinar, to ensure that we can identify and deploy the solution that best fits our registrants needs.



AIPLA has sought CLE accreditation* in the following states for credit(s): 
*CLE accreditations updated upon receipt.

​Alabama 1.50
Louisiana​ 1.50
​Alaska ​Maine ​1.50 ​Pennsylvania 1.50
​Arkansas ​Minnesota ​Rhode Island
​California 1.50
​Mississippi 1.50 ​South Carolina
​Colorado 2.00
​Missouri 1.80
​Delaware 1.50
​Montana 1.50
​Texas 1.50
​Florida ​Nebraska 1.50
​Utah (self-study)
​Nevada ​Vermont 1.50
​Hawaii 1.50 ​New Jersey
​Virginia 1.50
​Idaho ​New Mexico 1.50 ​Washington 1.50
​New York
​West Virginia
​Indiana ​North Carolina
​Wisconsin ​1.50
​Iowa 2.00
​North Dakota
​Wyoming 1.50
​Kansas ​1.50 ​Ohio ​1.50
​Oklahoma 2.00
CLE Restrictions: 
ATTENTION attorneys in LouisianaOhioPennsylvania and Utah
These states mandate attorneys can only view a webinar independently at their own computer to receive CLE credit.  Multiple attendees prohibited.
ATTENTION attorneys in Arizona
Arizona does not certify courses or providers. Arizona lawyers are required to independently review AZ's regulations and make their own determination that it qualifies for credit towards their MCLE requirements. MCLE Regulation 104(A) identifies the standards to apply.  AIPLA will email an attendance affidavit to registrants requesting AZ CLE credit after the webinar.
ATTENTION attorneys in New Hampshire
New Hampshire attendees must self-determine whether a program is eligible for credit, and self-report their attendance according to NH Supreme Court Rule 53.  The New Hampshire Minimum Continuing Legal Education (NHMCLE) Board does not approve or accredit CLE activities for the NH Minimum CLE requirement.  AIPLA will email an attendance affidavit to registrants requesting NH CLE credit after the webinar.   


Disclaimer:  AIPLA is a nonprofit national bar association.  The sole purpose of this CLE program is to provide educational and informational content.  AIPLA does not provide legal services or advice.  The opinions, views and other statements expressed by contributors to this CLE program are solely those of the contributors.  These opinions, views and statements of the contributors do not necessarily represent those of AIPLA and should not be construed as such.